Toleration vs. Compassion

This case examines the Australian referendum on indigenous rights, specifically focusing on the establishment of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice. The conceptual framework for analysis centres on the comparison between toleration and compassion.

The referendum, which occurred on October 14, 2023, serves as a significant event to explore the implications of these concepts on societal dynamics and the resulting policy outcomes. The overview of the case positions the Australian referendum within the regulatory rights prism, highlighting the presence of exclusionary forces and the potential for resentment and rejection among coexisting groups.

The toleration vs. compassion dynamic becomes a critical lens for understanding the societal interplay leading up to the referendum. Tolerance is described as establishing a de facto hierarchical relationship, potentially hindering genuine understanding and cohesion.

In contrast, compassion, rooted in recognizing the suffering of others, is seen as having the potential to transcend hierarchical structures, emphasizing its role in eliminating discrimination, fostering social ties, and influencing legislative frameworks. The dialogues initiated by compassion are portrayed as challenging dominant ideologies and contributing to a more just and inclusive society.

Context

Exclusionary

Belonging

Resentful

Outcome

Rejection

Stephen Sawyer
Stephen Sawyer

PI of WP2 and responsible for France data collection

Zona Zarić
Zona Zarić

Postdoctoral Fellow and WP2 co-lead

Learn more about this topic

Fallacies in the Concept of Gender in Iraq

After 2003, Iraq made significant strides towards integrating human rights into its national framework, spurred by its interim and subsequent 2005 permanent constitution which ...

Freedom of Expression in an Era of Extremism

This case-study explores a good and a bad example of balances being struck around freedom of expression and the protection of minorities or national ...

Northern Ireland: a Case-Study of Bringing Extremists in From the Cold

There are lessons for the rest of Europe and beyond in countering everyday extremism, as well as terrorism and populism, from the conflict, known ...

Affirmative Action

This case delves into the recent civil rights investigation initiated by the United States Department of Education into Harvard University’s legacy admissions policy. Following ...

Read the whole case

Our Regulatory Rights Toolkit for Attuning Everyday Extremism is available free of charge and will allow you to delve deeper into the topics of your interest.